Debunking Paleo Myths

Print Friendly

So, you want to eat Paleo? As you may already know, my family eats Paleo about 80% of the time. I chose specifically not to call my blog a “Paleo” blog because we occasionally eat rice, potatoes, dairy and corn. I didn’t want to get called out for not being “Paleo” when I’m just sharing recipes that work for us. Some people are turned off to Paleo for multiple reasons, some of which you’ll find below. Have you found yourself believing these myths?

Myth #1: Paleo = Subsisting on animal flesh

Image credit: Google images

Despite what you might read about the Paleo diet, it’s not all about the meat. Yes, animal protein is a large portion of what we eat:

But it’s important to consider meat quality when you’re thinking of a Paleo “diet.” Eating a bunch of grain-fed, antibiotic-filled conventional meat is not going to do anything for anyone except clog arteries and give people a host of other problems. Check out THIS article for more info. If buying grass-fed meat regularly isn’t an option for you, however, it would be better to add in more veggies to your meals than to gorge yourself on grain-fed meat.

Myth #2: Paleo = Not Enough Calcium Intake

Image Credit: Google Images

Ah, the old calcium debate. I’ve had lots of people bring this up to me, including a guy at Costco just recently (some of you may remember my Facebook post about it). Many people believe the only way to get good calcium is by eating dairy products. Did you know that one 4-oz serving of kale has the same amount of calcium as a cup of milk? THIS article on Harvard’s website states that “Milk is actually only one of many sources of calcium—and there are some important reasons why milk may not be the best source for everyone.” The article also talks about the benefits of legumes as a calcium source, but there’s a big debate around legume consumption, and that’s for another day. Check out the full article HERE.

Point being, there are many great sources for calcium. Try to get rid of the brainwashing we’ve all received over the years saying milk is the best way to get it. It’s also argued that our bodies absorb more calcium from veggies than we do from milk. Dr. Joel Fuhrman, a family physician who specializes in nutrition-based treatments writes, “Green vegetables also have calcium absorption rates of over 50 percent, compared with about 32 percent for milk. And, since animal protein induces calcium excretion in the urine, compared to dairy, the calcium retention from vegetables is higher.  All green vegetables are high in calcium.” See the rest of that article HERE, and maybe think twice before you guzzle down that chocolate milk.

Myth #3: Paleo = Never feeling full

Image Credit: Google Images

I’ve had people ask me how I can feel full on meat, veggies and fruits. Well, my friends, it is what it is! Although a big ol’ bowl of cereal may fill me up temporarily, I’ve found that when I eat a piece of quality meat, some veggies and some fruit, I get full and that fullness actually lasts. In one study published in the April 2011 issue of “Obesity,” “overweight men placed on a low-calorie diet who ate three high-protein meals a day had greater evening and late-night fullness than those on a lower-protein diet.” You can read more on that HERE. The great thing about eating whole foods is that you don’t have to calorie count, just eat when you’re hungry and pack in those veggies! Seriously, they fill you up more than you may think!

Myth #4: Paleo = Food boredom

Image Credit: Google Images

I’m really not sure why this is such a big one. Actually, I kind of get it. When we first started eating Paleo, I got into a major rut and felt like eating this way for the rest of our lives would kill us from boredom. That’s why I started this blog. It’s amazing how many different ways you can cook a vegetable. I mean, c’mon, when God created the world, don’t you think He knew what he was doing? I don’t think he “forgot” to create crackers and cereal and a bunch of processed foods. He had it perfect, and we’ve messed it up! There are endless possibilities when it comes to recipes. The Internet is an incredible resource, and there are SO MANY great blogs out there with recipes that will make your mouth water. Here are a few of my favorites:

The Clothes Make the Girl (THIS cookbook will give you hope that eating this healthy can, in fact, be amazing!)

The Food Lovers’ Kitchen (THIS cookbook was one of the first I bought when we changed our diet)

Nom Nom Paleo (I’ve heard awesome things about THIS cookbook!)

Health Bent (Another incredible resource of recipes HERE)

Against All Grain (HERE’S her great cookbook!)

Check them out and be inspired!

Myth #5: Paleo = Never enjoying “normal” foods again

Image Credit: Google Images

Your life is not over! It’s just beginning. Don’t believe that if you start eating Paleo, you can never eat a “normal” treat again. As I’ve said before, eating this way is not about perfection, it’s about progress. No one expects you to never eat a cupcake again. Enjoy your life–you only live once! But after you enjoy some off the chain cheesecake, go back to your “home base.” Don’t see that treat as a failure, see it as a treat. Tomorrow, eat a great breakfast. Fill yourself up with some eggs and veggies. Eat a yummy grain-free lunch and dinner, and go to bed that night remembering how awesome that cheesecake was and how great it was to indulge and then get right back to eating to fuel your body. Does that make sense? Like I said, we eat Paleo about 80% of the time. I have milkshakes. I go out with friends and eat dessert. Once in awhile, I have pizza. The real deal–not just a sorry copycat. And that’s ok. As a matter of fact, I think it’s healthy. I’m not saying the pizza is healthy, but being a person who eats “off the grid” in moderation is healthy! If you become a food Nazi, you will fail. Live your life knowing you eat food to fuel your body, but that you have no problem letting your hair down and eating something different once in awhile. IT’S OK!!

And so, that’s what I have to say about that. I hope I’ve dispelled some Paleo myths for you. Holla at me if you have any questions!
FRESH Posts In Your Inbox
Life Made Full
Join the 1000's of Readers That
Receive Our New Posts By Email.


  1. Jill says

    I believe in calcium without milk but I still wonder if I am getting enough.
    Also I am having a hard time figuring out the 80% -or the 20% I guess. I think my children are getting mixed messages. It’s hard for them to understand we eat “that stuff” some of the time -why is it ok today and not tomorrow. Regular pizza and ice cream is really the only “cheat” I think we want (need) but once we go there how often is the right balance. I feel like once the door is open it’s hard to shut it. Having it once leads to much more than I feel comfortable with. So I find it easier to have it never – but I’m feeling that that’s not right for us either. Do people set up a once per week thing?

  2. radlandon says

    Hi, Jill! I struggled with this for awhile as well. Eventually, I settled on when we are at home, we pretty much always eat Paleo (with the occasional potatoes or rice or popcorn). When we go to a restaurant or a kids’ party, I let the kids pick what they want. I continually remind them what the better choices are, but that they ultimately will be responsible for what they put into their bodies. I want them to make connections NOW about their food choices so that when they get older they can make informed decisions on their own. Does that make sense? It’s a journey figuring out what works for your family, but I wanted to make sure my kids aren’t completely deprived so they feel controlled and then rebel when they turn into teenagers. lol

  3. says

    Love your blog!

    I’ve gotta say that #5 is SO much easier once you have a better relationship with food. That’s the biggest, and best, thing Paleo has done for me. Now when I indulge, I do it without the guilt because I know that it’s just a small treat in addition to the nourishing choices I made that week, instead of just throwing it on top of fast food and boxed junk.

    We’re Primal, as I just can’t kick my Greek yogurt and string cheese habit, but we’re striving to maintain an 80/20 approach as well. I figure that means we can have our pizza and movie night on Fridays and a big, ‘conventional’ breakfast on Sundays (though I found a fantastic pancake recipe on Urban Poser that the whole family likes more than ‘real’ pancakes now), a fun lunch with the kids during the week, and a snack or treat should we go to a playdate or party. 4 meals out of a whole week seems like a good enough balance to keep me from going on a total binge spiral.

  4. Tracy says

    Agree with all of these except the “lean” meat. My Paleo understanding is that animal fat (from humanely, organically raised animals) is good for us and eating enough of it obviates #3. Praise the Lard!

  5. says

    Love this!

    Number 1 is definitely my biggest pet peeve. I actually shy away from telling people I eat paleo because when I do they instantly assume all I eat is meat and offer me only meat dishes or tell me to switch to a plant based diet.

    I wish more people would do their research and realize that paleo people want to focus on nutrient dense foods more so than just eating meat all the time.

  6. Jennifer says

    I’m not sure about that food pyramid–where is it from?
    There are so many “ways” to do paleo. Most emphasise vegetables.

    Personally, I eat mostly veg, a fair amount of protein (not lean), some nuts, and a verh small amount of (low sugar) fruit. that works well for me. During the transition to paleo, I think extra protein can help with leveling out blood sugar. After that, I don’t think most of us need huge amounts of protein foods. Quality rather than quality.

Speak Your Mind